Deadmusic For Deadhaters?

dayofthedeadalbumart2016The National’s Aaron and Bryce Dessner have – five years after its inception – released their 59-track, six-hour tribute to the music of the Grateful Dead, Day Of The Dead, to raise money for the HIV/AIDS charity Red Hot. Underpinned by The National, over 50 different artists and bands have recorded their versions of Dead originals, covers they made their own and even a couple of ‘inspired by’ tracks. The avowedly Dead-hating and -agnostic Observer/Guardian critics gave it 4 stars; from the other end of the telescope, as a Dead-lover, I think I agree.

Last month, Carole submitted the take on Sugaree by Phosphorescent, Jenny Lewis & Friends as an Earworm, and that typifies one strand of cover found in this expansive set: the almost-straight version. These are perhaps the least successful to my ears, as they invariably omit some of the more subtle aspects found in a Dead version: the drumming is usually rockier, the bass is more static, the voice often cuts against the emotion of the lyrics and some colour chords and harmonies are left out…..but one man gathers what another man spills, so this may be the way forward for non-Deadheads.

As you go deeper into the (excellently-curated) set, several less faithful covers appear, where the rhythm and mood of the song has been changed, where lyrics are delivered from a different perspective, where modern psychedelia has been added. There are also those covers where the original music has all but been discarded and the song planted in a different genre altogether. And then there are the songs that exist almost in memory form, where the lyrics have been radically altered or omitted and the music is a series of nods and winks to those who remember the originals.

I’m not yet comfortable with The Walkmen’s fairground take on Ripple, but there is nothing bad here and a lot that is very good. And not a single Jerry Garcia impersonation in earshot!

Here are ten of my faves from a first listen:

Loser – Ed Droste, Binki Shapiro & Friends
An example of the simplified cover, with less interesting bass and drums than a Dead version but an attitude that makes up for it.

Truckin’ – Marijuana Deathsquads
To transform this archetypical chugging Dead story so dramatically and yet retain its essence takes imagination and talent.

Help On The Way – Béla Fleck
Including Slipknot!, this is a near-faithful rendition, played and sung beautifully but with different instrumentation and some superb improvisation.

Estimated Prophet – The Rileys
Minimalist composer Terry Riley and his son Gyan use the instrumental motifs from the song (written in Terry’s favourite 7/4 time signature) yet replace all the words with the imagined voice of a Middle Eastern prophet.

Rosemary – Mina Tindle & Friends
A short glimpse through the mirror into another time and place.

What’s Become Of The Baby – s t a r g a z e
The Dead’s deliberately weird evocation from Aoxomoxoa given near-substance and ephemeral beauty under the menace. Is it part of an ancient sacrificial ritual?

Cumberland Blues – Charles Bradley and Menahan Street Band
Ditching its last sections entirely, the song once thought to be a traditional country ditty by a real Cumberland miner is here warped into a dirty blues.

Black Peter – Anohni and yMusic
The words have been butchered, the music broken apart and the original point of the song discarded….but the new song created is, I have to admit (despite myself), rather gorgeous.

Easy Wind – Bill Callaghan
The tale of hard labour and hard women that Pigpen told with energy and attitude (and a waltz-time section) takes a seat with a bottle of Jack Daniels and some reverb.

Uncle John’s Band – Lucius
A quintessential Deadsong, moulded and dressed for different ears, yet retaining the spirit of the original. And some of the odd timing.

Here’s a YT playlist of Grateful Dead versions of the same songs, if you don’t find comparisons odious….

15 thoughts on “Deadmusic For Deadhaters?

  1. I saw the review and thought it looked interesting, but couldn’t face the full 59 tracks – thanks for distilling it down.
    I haven’t listened to the originals (if such a term can be used for Dead songs where every version is a cover of their own tunes!) yet, but was somewhat inevitably drawn to the noisy/weird ones – Truckin’ and What’s Become of the Baby being the standouts. I always have a lot of time for Bill Callahan too, so that was ace.

  2. Well, that was absolutely fascinating. On a first hearing the ones that impressed me the most were Estimated Prophet, What’s Become Of The Baby and Uncle John’s Band. I especially liked the neoclassical approach taken with “What’s Become Of The Baby”. In places it really reminded me of 1920s and 30s Stravinsky. With his background in 20th century classical music, I am sure that this track would please Phil Lesh enormously. I also loved the approach taken by The Rileys.

    I need to listen to all of this again. In fact, I probably need to buy the complete album.

      • I bought mine in an actual shop! I came across one of the remaining hmv stores (in good old Stockport) on Saturday and popped in on the off-chance. The guy behind the counter found it under ‘Compilations’ – which is where everyone looks for new music, right? – and I had to explain to him what it was. ‘I like The National’, he said, and started to take an interest.
        I wonder how many fans of the artists in the set don’t even know it exists? Deadheads do, of course, but we’re not the target audience (I hope). With a bit of marketing, it could possibly sell well….

  3. Hello strangers! This has gone into my online shopping basket, but as we’re away next week (and our delivery agent has the work ethic and brains of a dead sloth), I’m not ordering it until we get back.

  4. I’ll buy this if for no other reason than it is a charitable project. Oh, and it involves The National. I’ve heard a few covers already.. What struck me of what I heard was that some bands took a Dead song and turned it into their own. Mm, that sounds dumb, but when I heard The War on Drugs, for example, do Toich of Grey, it sounded just like a track from their latest album. Whatever there was of the original was subsumed by TWOD sound. I’m sure there will be gems, just like there are on the Dylan covers album Chimes of Freedom, another charity album. Is it ironic that one of the great covers bands of all times should themselves be so extensively covered?

  5. Looking forward to listening when I get a minute. I don’t know the originals so I might enjoy the covers without any frame of reference! (I will listen to the originals afterwards).

  6. 6 hours?! Shorter than one of their shows then. Would have preferred avoiding the house band approach, but I’m sure I’ll find something to like given some of the participants.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.